Key Lime Pie Bakery Menu (Update 2025)

Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West, FL, is a must-visit for all dessert lovers. Specializing in Key Lime pies, this bakery also offers a variety of other delicious treats like cookies and taffy. Customers rave about the delectable pies, with many claiming it's the best in town. The cozy bakery exudes good vibes and provides seating options both indoors and outdoors. With friendly and knowledgeable hosts, you'll feel right at home as you indulge in their sweet creations. The frozen Key Lime treats dipped in chocolate are a standout favorite among visitors. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Key Lime Pie Bakery is the perfect spot to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings. Don't miss out on trying their signature Key Lime pies – you won't be disappointed.