Welcome to Key Lime Pie Bakery
Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West, FL, is a charming spot offering a variety of delicious key lime treats. Known for their creamy and flavorful key lime pies, including a tempting coconut variation, this bakery also serves frozen key lime treats dipped in chocolate. Customers rave about the friendly service and cozy ambiance, making it a must-visit for tourists craving the iconic Key West dessert. Whether you're a key lime pie enthusiast or simply looking to satisfy your sweet tooth, Key Lime Pie Bakery is the perfect stop for a taste of authentic Florida key lime goodness.
-
412 Greene St Key West, FL 33040 Hotline: (305) 296-9515
Welcome to Key Lime Pie Bakery, a delightful spot located at 412 Greene St in Key West, FL. This charming bakery specializes in all things key lime, offering a variety of delicious treats that are sure to satisfy any sweet craving.
With a range of options including the classic key lime pie, chocolate dipped key lime pies, and even key lime taffy, Key Lime Pie Bakery is a key lime lover's paradise. The bakery also caters to those with dietary restrictions, providing dairy-free and gluten-free options for all to enjoy.
Customers rave about the delicious pies and treats at Key Lime Pie Bakery, with many highlighting the perfect balance of sweetness and citrus flavor in each bite. The cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and convenient amenities such as free Wi-Fi and outdoor seating make this bakery a must-visit when in Key West.
Whether you're a longtime key lime pie enthusiast or simply looking to satisfy your sweet tooth, Key Lime Pie Bakery is the perfect place to indulge in all things key lime. So, stop by, grab a slice of pie, and savor the flavors of this beloved Florida staple.
Free tasting of cookies, fast service, seating indoors and outside!Knowledgeable hosts with ready smiles!
Delicious pie, as we expected! We did notice that a lot of the bagged key lime treats were not made in Florida. That was a little disappointing. (Hence, the 4 stars instead of 5)
Service was great! The key lime pie and chocolate dipped one that was frozen on a stick were excellent. Best place to get great key lime pie in Key West.
Went to Key West for the first time and knew I had to get a Key lime pie. First of all the store/bakery was very nice and had good vibes. Second of all the Key lime pie was amazing at a 9.5/10 it had great flavor and was delicious. Overall the food, shop, and service was very good.
Besssst key lime pie. We tried a few and nothing beats this one! Come and try it, you won't be disappointed.
Yes!!! The original Keylime pie is delicious. Not too sweet - not too sour. just right !! must come here to have a piece!!! The inside is nothing to write home about just simple and the service was nice.
It's all about Key Lime! Though we have tried the Key Lime pie from Miami, someone suggested that this place sells the best Key Lime Pie in Key West! Boy! That's right. The best key lime pie! Creamy, soft crust and perfect citrus flavor! Along with the original Key lime pie, they serve a variety of key lime pies as well. We loved the coconut one! Cute little bakery. Always busy. But the service is great. They've got couple of tables outside. It's so lovely to sit, enjoy the pie on a sunny day!
Waited 21 years to taste this again. Nothing better the a frozen Key lime dipped in chocolate. Most likely the best in town.
If you're a tourist and love key lime pie; this is your place! Everything is key lime! Super cute shop, they offer coffee also. The key lime pie was delicious and the coconut key lime pie was just as delicious. The key lime taffy was a tasty surprise as well. The lady working here was so sweet. Again if you like key lime pie come here!
This was my fave key lime pie in Key West. Just the right amount of sweet. Wasn't too rich and heavy. The staff is nice. Tons of stuff to look at and buy in the shop.